This is a set of issues we're dealing with the OpenTripPlanner tool of relevance to the OSSTIP project.

Concerns with accuracy of OTP Analyst Isochrones in late evening or overnight[edit | edit source]

Created: 2014-03-13
Status: Emailed to OTP mailing lists, created issue on Github, possible code debugging needed.

Issue is at :- https://github.com/opentripplanner/OpenTripPlanner/issues/1373

See mailing list posts:

Concerns about maxTransfers value too low by default[edit | edit source]

(Moved from original location in OSSTIP/Project_blog#2013-08-29_:-_Making_some_progress_with_OTP_Batch_Analyst_for_calculating_OD_Matrices_and_more_advanced_visualisations)

Created: 2013-08-29
Status: Ongoing.

See:- https://groups.google.com/d/msg/opentripplanner-users/m8xSRFOA8nY/e-UnlH2tQ4EJ

Hi there,

I've been using OpenTripPlanner as part of a research project to propose improvements to Melbourne, Australia's public transport network - and its shaping up really well so far.

A concern that arose today though from a transport planning perspective :- it appears the default value of maxTransfers=2 in the RoutingRequest class ?? I discovered this when doing some batch analyst tests and it was giving a -1 trip time value for several trips until I increased this parameter.

As a public transport-oriented researcher and advocate for sustainable transport I'm just a bit concerned with having a max transfer this low by default.

The reason is that a strong theme of research into transport best-practice in recent years is that for transit to compete with the car in terms of coverage, we need to plan entire networks that _do_ sometimes require several transfers to access all of a large urban region - but the transfer times should be minimised using pulse timetables or high-frequency services. See e.g. http://web.archive.org/web/20130512130113/http://www.newsouthbooks.com.au/books/transport-for-suburbia_beyond-the-automobile-age/ or http://www.humantransit.org/2009/04/why-transferring-is-good-for-you-and-good-for-your-city.html

So could I suggest at least 3 as the default?? What do other users think?

I know its just a value that can be overridden in the application-context.xml :- but in my experience as a developer and scientist in computational modelling, default parameter values really do matter ;)

Page data
Authors Patrick Sunter
Published 2014
License CC-BY-SA-4.0
Impact Number of views to this page and its redirects. Updated once a month. Views by admins and bots are not counted. Multiple views during the same session are counted as one. 74
Issues Automatically detected page issues. Click on them to find out more. They may take some minutes to disappear after you fix them. No main image
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.