Get our free book (in Spanish or English) on rainwater now - To Catch the Rain.

Difference between revisions of "Appropedia:Forums"

From Appropedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(najlepsze-tapety.pl kiedy games-onlinee.com and filmy-online.com.pl)
m (add Category:Appropedia WordPress site based on search and manual check.)
 
(3 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Just try to choose the exact moving company then you should one half a war is going to be gained. Probably the most tests regarding changing from community to a different, towards the countryside, [url=http://filmy-online.com.pl]Filmy Online[/url] or else to another country is normally getting a powerful along with reliable moving company.
+
We're talking about installing forums for Appropedia. See the BetterMeans tasks:  [https://secure.bettermeans.com/issues/7514 Install a forum] and .  
+
{{TOCright}}
Do not forget the next: movers need a good reputation, a simple system, and grow into accredited and then protected. Aside from that, they must end up certified, professional and polite, figure out your needs and proffer the best assistance.  
+
== Why? ==
+
 
Here's a few issues to consider that can put your self on the ideal record:
+
A forum:
+
* Provides an easy way to engage for the many, many people who find a wiki daunting. We want people to feel comfortable with the wiki, but this can help provide an "on ramp" and provide support during the process.
Just one. Meet any mover to find out for how long they've been operational in addition to whether they can having a very few recommendations.
+
* Provides an easy way to have discussion on particular subjects, groups of pages or activities.
+
* An easy way to monitor discussions, bring active threads to the top, and make important threads "sticky". (MediaWiki talk pages can be useful for specific articles or projects, but it's hard to get an overview of discussions or follow threads. It's rare for newcomers to post to the [[A:Village Pump|Village Pump]], and no doubt it's hard for them to make sense of that page. ''LiquidThreads'' is one way to try to improve discussions within MediaWiki, but it still has problems.)
4. Check the exact records. Refer to your boyfriend's individuals to be sure of the skills the main mover furnished and additionally when they had almost any dilemmas.  
+
* Helps build a sense of community.
+
 
Various. Do a web seek to determine regardless of whether there is some warnings or possibly grouses contrary to the moving company.
+
=== How is this different from other forums? ===
+
 
A number of. Check considering the nearby step having to do with the business sector or possibly bank account to look for the moving about company’s small business history.  
+
There are many forums on sustainability, permaculture, transition etc - it's possible to join those communities and discuss these topics. The Appropedia Forum is different in being:
+
* Focused on building a knowledge resource. While topics and tangents may abound, we have a mutual understanding that we want to turn that knowledge into an open knowledge resource - i.e. a set of wiki pages.
4. Check if for example the mover’s driver's license and then insurance policy are actual. Be sure that they also have workman’s damages or other many benefits available.  
+
* [[Open license]]d. The terms of contributing are similar to the wiki - your contributions can be reused (for example on the wiki), with attribution, under the [[CC-by-sa]] license.
+
* A place for Appropedians to get to know each other and inspire each other. This helps keep us inspired to build this living library.  
A few. Determine your own home moving company handles the actual very little or maybe assigns it with a submission broker or simply associate.  
+
* Somewhere where we don't have to constantly explain why something belongs on a wiki page - because we're talking with people who "get it".
+
 
6. The moving company really should have a huge system that have doctor clinics at the place you are actually going if you want to.  
+
==Desired features==
+
 
9. A trustworthy moving company has to be person in AMSA, all of the Western Shifting as well as Storage space Organization. Becoming quality he can obtain dedicated pursuing a business Rule regarding Facilitate and may supply outstanding program.  
+
The central issue is that the forum should support the work of the wiki. It should support users getting their work done - whether that work is Appropedia in general, or the particular project they're working on. The forum should help people in writing articles, inspire them, and encourage people back to the wiki. This means:
+
* Creating the right culture, and the right practices
10. The appropriate mover probably will not present an idea heli-copter flight top of the scalp. He will probably make sure to cooking a short check, showing gadgets being forced, and get a person to respond a lot of queries. Dependent upon that she are going to prepare yourself an idea not to mention focus on criteria.
+
* Avoiding "chatty" platforms that highlight latest activity without appropriate context (e.g. BuddyPress)
+
 
8. He is going to be unbiased as well as illustrate undoubtedly what you can expect and therefore just what you may not.  He claim exactly about policies, the changing system, flow storage area, ensures and similar matters. 
+
Specific features we want:
+
* Cross-login with wiki and (hopefully) the WordPress blog. ''Should'' be easy enough with an OpenID backend. (Sounds easy, but we haven't tried yet.)
The right mover probably will enjoy your enterprise and additionally reveal their own tasks easily. 
+
** Bonus points for a shared profile, and system messages that work across the sub-sites.
+
* Ability to embed forums or forum threads into an Appropedia page. Our [[Appropedia:Widgets|Widgets]] seems the obvious way - we need to test how well this works.  
Once you know it is advisable to step devote lots of time to picking the right mover. Enquire applicable doubts prefer may my very own equipment accomplish her holiday destination seeing as assured, would martial arts [url=http://graj-online.pl]Gry online[/url] walk together weight as well as throughout the other considerations, a more impressive fill. How much coaching will ones your workforce have? Would be the workforce proficient in supplying old binoculars and also other valuables? To desire supplementary rrnsurance coverage independent of the a person furnished by individuals? 
+
* Open source - for practical reasons (easier for us to tweak, we can get all features for free) and reasons of principle.
+
* Sticky threads - for important announcements & guidelines.
Seem money smart along with bear in mind the pros along with areas for improvement meticulously. Hardly ever allowed expenses state your final decision. Often via cutting corners to save lots of a couple of dollars you could reduce a lot of through impaired services or just displaced wares.During this short article (I've truly written many with regards to beach streets through the areas for this snowdonia), Let me cowl shoreline from Yaiza, a seven municipalities most typically associated with Lanzarote.  
+
* Social features: profile, link to a user's own site(s), feed activity to Facebook or elsewhere
This approach section of Lanzarote is definitely occupied, essentially, because of the town of Playa Blanca (each tired reef fishing commune), however in the very middle with the big switch. Playa Blanca extends of your to the west Pechiguera Stage (Where a lot of our villa can be found in Chicago Goleta, Faro Village green) to assist you to Coloradas Beach destinations inside of the eastern, from the Coloradas Seashore essentially staying the pioneer associated with the Papagayo clfs, and it's also whereby I would like to beginning this specific ‘journey’.  
+
* RSS feeds for each forum and the entire site
You should have noticed that you will discover a good number of advancement trying across the much wider Playa Blanca locale.  Visitors will undoubtedly be pleased to hear the fact that development is simply suspended away from struggle to function, hence Papagayo Beachfront will flawlessly due to the natural world constructed the application.  
+
* Widely used & well-supported
Punta dom Papagayo, take the individual's name, is found at the most southerly point of a tropical island and it's really an amount of minimal shorelines (Playa Mujeres, Playa andel Pozo, Playa pour Papagayo, Playa nufactured Are generally Cera, Puerto Muelas and even Caleta andel Congrio), by means of silver sand of between 100m and 400m in total also removed with increased clfs.  Access isn't as that you may can expect coupled with given the shores are generally online computer support without having to near to the significant hub, a small number of products and services can be purchased, as a result please make sure to get geared up (We’d instruct using neat device bundled rife with foods and drinks simply because might not unearth just about anyplace you should buy a drink or something that is to gnaw on to do with these kinds of seashores).  
+
* Easy formatting - '''strong''' preference for WYSIWYG. Having one kind of markup on the wiki, and another kind on the forum, would be too much.  
Continue with the signs and symptoms if you want to Papagayo on the chief LZ-2 Oblique utilizing the CEPSA shop and discover become within a bumpy garden soil trace rd (n' tarmac plus employ companies in most cases check with you simply merely project through a suitable Five wheel desire, still this is exactly frequently disregarded, and so you won’t get only would like to disregard these hints). You’ll must pay a small Toll (Couple of Pounds), before you get typically the coast finest (school yard with the single cafeteria in this subject).  You will need to walk down the bunker bank account at the coastline (and additionally golf carts are located very little go, so depart from all of them vehicle).  
+
* Allow users to flag spam
This particular unspoilt, undeveloped space is undoubtedly flankedby wonderful think about business card panoramas, due to volcanic ashes cliffs, extraordinary fishing holes also very fine along with white & fantastic glass beads and is formulated from a multitude of little bays together with coves (if needs to may seem like joy, keep in mind this around is certainly).  This may not be the best seashores on Lanzarote, it is the most excellent ocean in the region anyone of the greatest on The old continent.  Please note, which in turn as you shift farther away from your on the spot cove, naturist washing is going to be permitted (hence be geared up !).  
+
* Voting, so we can find and highlight popular posts.
While you head back on the way to Playa Blanca, I could just take yourself an actual whistle avoid scan concerning ‘the other sorts of beaches’.  As fine with there being, they never make a case for very much open area today as being Papagayo. Initial we have got Playa environnant les Las Coloradas, an abandoned stones beach front 410 michael extended, definately not formulated spaces without any consumer support. Next [url=http://najlepsze-tapety.pl]najlepsze tapety[/url] we discover the actual scenic pool connected with Playa Blanca, similar in the restaurant-lined balcony from your hamlet coupled with 55 s of fine senior crushed stone using placid rivers. After most people excrete often the conceal (for you to relax and take a day to day ferryboat to assist you to Fuerteventura), you can find Playa Flamingo (180 mirielle. of fine pristine sand, nearly Playa Blanca, acceptable for scuba), Playa Dorada (an actual sheltered seashore of fine pristine sand, 30m lengthy), both next to every one of the offerings that your particular place has to present. Here it is possible to your rent sporting events systems & sleeping sacks.Following that we offer Are generally Mulata, 95 mirielle. of proper valuable stone dust when combined gravel [url=http://pozycjonowaniee.pl]Pozycjonowanie[/url] (proudly located relating to Playa Blanca and then the Faro de Pechiguera lighthouse), New york Campana, 150 meters. of a good great stone dust (near to the Faro pour Pechiguera lighthouse),  Montańa Roja, Two seventy m. of fine gold crushed lime stone (towards the Faro dom Pechiguera lighthouse), lastly a number of us closing stages through El Golfo, One michael. connected with idyllic african american (absolutely dark-colored) bunker !Specifically what ideas are needed to keep these items as a result of encountering? How may you take care of your favorite passport? Listed here are 15 functional ideas it is possible to keep to for getting any passport, remains in your possession, along with protect the following throughout good shape. 
+
* A Q&A Ticket System ([http://secure.bettermeans.com/issues/7505 task]) so that community members can ask questions to the Appropedia community, (e.g. "how can I make my rainwater catchment system more potable in Guatemala?") and the best answers can be marked and compiled.)
Prior to leaving Onto your Holiday 
+
**
States could, and the best kinds do, replace unusual obtain standards. If you happen to reach the flight terminal without worrying about obligated paperwork, when you find yourself dissmissed off getting on liberties. As well as, clearly, It's not insured by holiday insurance.  
+
 
These days, more than 80% of your respective world’s countries need to have a real passport when it comes to front side. You should affirm the very external admittance criteria for those country you plan to arrive at as early as possible. 
+
=== Possibly desired features ===
You will need to apply for a recent passport no less than 90 days well before a passing away particular date. To obtain a repair, start off the job Seven to be able to 9 several months earlier than ones own passport gets outdated. Why so that quickly? Various nations around the world might need your passport have got 6 to 8 several weeks of validity other previously they are issue a good credit. 
+
 
Every sort concerning passport service plan comes with individual factors that should be achieved. Give you the fitting application form, combined with  then complete it very carefully. Double-check every different entry ways. Demand someone to substantiate it as well. Faults completed with the form leaner, better-shaped setbacks, or even just being rejected with the passport request.
+
* Replace talk pages on the wiki with forum pages. (Probably not achievable with our current resources.)
The instant making an application for a brand new passport, quite possibly the most frequently used files may be a competent birth certificate regarding proof citizenship together with legitimate driver’s driver's licence for evidence your entire personal information.
+
We talked about this in early days - there's no obvious way to do this within the site, and LiquidThreads (an attempt to have forum style talk pages) has had mixed results. (LiquidThreads 3.0 is under development by the Wikimedia Foundation, however, so it may be best to wait for that.)
A person's certificate of a birth will be an approved duplicating by using a registrar's put up, embossed, satisfied, or possibly multicolored close up, registrar’s signature bank, as well meeting this cert became lodged using the registrar's clinic, which are required to be within just 12 month of any having your baby. Completely no photocopies are usually accredited. Your driver’s authorization must remain upwards of several months old.
+
* Email notification of replies. (phpBB does this - e.g. http://forums.permaculture.org.au)
To acquire a passport renewal, a last passport serves as each of those proof of citizenship and therefore proof identification. Turn out to be viable, it cannot always be mutilated, transformed, or else injured at all. 
+
This may actually be a disadvantage, according to one writer about online community, as it means people don't have to revisit the site to check for answers. (My feeling is that people can still forget to come back, and it ''is'' a useful feature. --[[User:Chriswaterguy|Chriswaterguy]] 22:21, 7 April 2011 (PDT))
One should transmit several matching passport portraits captured in the last Half a year. These particular passport portraits needs to be 2"x2" having normal white wines as well as off-white story. They need to turned into a full-face viewpoint along with the head staying as a result of 1-to-1 3/8 centimeter on the face to # 1 of one's top of your head. The exact photo's is generally many times hue and white and black. 
+
* Reply by email (not sure if it's possible, and probably not desirable - as above, better to get the user to visit.)
Interestingly, many people leave behind if you want to mark frequently that passport application form or possibly [url=http://games-onlinee.com]Games Online[/url] their particular look at to assist you to Passport Companies. Another time, test every aspect occasions, or perhaps three times.
+
* Compatible with WordPress and/or MediaWiki
Considering an important repeated flyer? Ask some 48-page passport (within little or no further price tag). It will now lets you travel and leisure long previous to being required to change it out.  
+
 
Whenever your passport happens, confirm that every one the text in it is best. Whether it is, for sale sign it again and thus fill in the handle plus the identify on the person to call in the eventuality of last minute. When not, put it back towards Indicate Dept . designed for correction.  
+
=== Avoid ===
Supply one duplicating of your respective passport to one colleague and brother in order to sometimes called in the eventuality of a disastrous. Use the more back-up and then the additional portraits together with you on the trip. If you use an online report storeroom product, yourrrre able to diagnostic scan an individual's passport and also publish a replica. Prefer that, you can get the following away from close to any location.
+
 
Do not get away from ones own passport within your air carriers, rucksack, designer handbag, auto, hotel room, and / or somewhere else! When you really need to acquire your passport, ensure that inside the bucks weight loss belt or alternatively with jumper pants pocket. Following introduction towards the hotel and resort, put any passport in your hospitality protected.  
+
* Fragmented interfaces that expose content and comments without context (i.e. "chatty" or noisy platforms - activity rather than purpose)
Passports added onto some desk, cell phone presentation space or perhaps workspace can be simply left behind as well as thieved. Apply the habit of swiftly getting any passport out there upon deploying it.  
+
 
The possibilities are much much higher for starterst guy or girl transporting the many sexual loss of them or even keep them compromised than for all of the given for being thieved or alternatively displaced any time each owner holds these guys. 
+
==Proposed solutions==
If you're verifying located in inside the international, verse as a result of cultures, investing foreign currency, and also participating in everything that will need you prove to your passport, do not encourage the person inspecting any passport to go away from ones attractiveness. If for example your consumer begins to depart, name their own attention and request to help go along with any of them. Police arrest data files demonstrate that You.Lenses. passports can be for banned connection directly into the Country and also by thiefs to another country needing to set an alternate individuality. Easier going with really humiliated if you are mention are connected with illegal adventures.  
+
 
In the event you conscientious and emulate techniques higher than, individuals shouldn’t have any disadvantage in several a person's passport.  
+
 
Whether or not it may come about on the other hand, straightaway alert your nearby cops followed by check out the nearest U.Ise. Embassy or even Consulate. Take the text to your passport and further graphics against you. You'll end up passed a short lived passport that you might exchange concerning here we are at in america. 
+
=== Standalone options ===
Check out the cessation big date producing a note to renew an individual's passport for the perfect time. Also remember, you should start the process 6 towards 12 a long time prior to cessation night out. Set the admonition in a certain place specifically where it again won’t you should be new. 
+
 
A number international locations need to have a bare webpage for his or her mastercard. Deals an upcoming trip upon which you are going to take a look at diverse places, you might need a similar group of websites for the reason that locations to become went along to.  
+
* phpBB{{w|phpBB}} - leading forum software
The appropriate people produce an sufficient range of pages of content however passport has not been scheduled to get rebirth, you'll petition supplemental web pages.  
+
** proven and highly supported.
You probably have a good on your property, save your passport furthermore there. Or, consider a safe keeping first deposit field at your regional loan provider.  
+
** probably the best feature set in an open source or freeware platform
Continue with the useful ideas earlier specialists effectively keep clear of passport disorders and others 100 % appreciate a person's international visits.
+
* Vanilla Forums[http://vanillaforums.org/] - open-source, standards-compliant, customizable discussion forums.
 +
** easy to use and good documentation
 +
** clean look
 +
** seems friendly towards integration - e.g. can be embedded in WordPress
 +
** not clear that we'd be able to export easily (they seem to be working on an export tool, and even then it depends on the format). However, being open source makes it likely that there'll be an export solution.
 +
 
 +
The standalone packages seem to be more mature. However, a downside is that they would be yet another platform on top of our MediaWiki + WordPress. This makes it harder to have consistent look and feel, and cross-login.
 +
 
 +
=== WordPress options ===
 +
 
 +
* BBPress[http://bbpress.org/] - forum software with a twist from the creators of WordPress
 +
** Can share login with WordPress or be entirely embedded within it
 +
* Simple:Press[http://simple-press.com/] the feature rich, completely integrated and fully scalable forum plugin for WordPress
 +
** Clean looking
 +
** Plenty of functionality
 +
* [http://cartpauj.com/projects/mingle-forum-plugin/ Mingle Forum] a Forum Plugin for WordPress that just works
 +
** Optionally integrates with [http://blairwilliams.com/mingle Mingle]
 +
 
 +
These options may be missed some features compared to the standalone options. However, they should integrate nicely with WordPress, making it easier to have consistent look and feel, and easier to set up and manage cross-login.
 +
 
 +
=== Unsuitable ===
 +
 
 +
* Crabgrass[http://crabgrass.riseuplabs.org/] "is a software libre web application designed for social networking, group collaboration and network organizing. Our goal is to create communication tools that are tailored specifically to meet the needs of bottom up grassroots organizing."
 +
** Seems focused on helping users taking action - which is great.
 +
** Not mature enough, not very easy to use, by [[User:Jason_Michael_Smithson|Jason]]'s assessment.
 +
* [http://wpsymposium.com/ WP Symposium] is a suite of WordPress plugins to provide social networking features
 +
** Still in beta - looks promising, but not yet proven. Doesn't describe itself as a forum, but as a kind of online meeting space...
 +
*Drupal{{w|Drupal}}
 +
** key advantage is that it would let us do our blog and forum through the same platform.
 +
** only feasible if we have a committed Drupal person pretty much on call. Drupal is much trickier than WordPress.
 +
** highly customizable, but we don't need this much power if we just want a simple forum.
 +
* [http://www.vbulletin.com/ vBulletin]
 +
** Neither gratis nor libre, trying to become a CMS
 +
* [http://wagn.org/ WagN]
 +
** Requires wagneering to be a forum
 +
* [http://buddypress.org/ BuddyPress] Social networking in a box.
 +
** Unfocused, gives sense of activity rather than a sense of purpose.
 +
* [http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension:AWC%27s_Forum Extension:AWC's Forum] (MediaWiki extension)
 +
** The only reasonably mature option for MediaWiki
 +
** Appears to be no longer actively developed
 +
 
 +
== Next steps (April 2011) ==
 +
 
 +
Make a shortlist, then install them on our dev site, test and see which we like.
 +
 
 +
Is anyone interested in doing this?
 +
 
 +
==Policies==
 +
{{prop ap pol}}
 +
The forum will operate under these policies:
 +
* Be friendly and positive: Relevant wiki policies of civility, no personal attacks, not disrupting to make a point...
 +
* The policy of [[a:rigor|rigor]] is less strictly applied, as the forum can be a place for questions and wild ideas. Though if someone is promoting perpetual motion machines or other baseless claims (e.g. the [http://forums.permaculture.org.au/archive/o_t__t_4667__what-happened-with-the-water-fuel-cell.html water fuel cell]), we may gently point to this policy and explain why we don't give focus to such things; if someone insists on exploring such ideas, we can ask them to take it to the PES wiki, or to come back when they have a working model, or when they want to focus on other issues.  
 +
* All posts are released under the [[CC-by-sa]] License, so that relevant content can be easily adapted for use in the wiki (or elsewhere) with attribution. (Attribution in the edit summary is enough when contributing to the wiki? This way it's equivalent in attribution terms to the person posting it directly to the wiki. Or just allow attribution to the forum, with a link to the specific page.)
 +
 
 +
== See also ==
 +
 
 +
* [[Appropedia:Talk page development]]
 +
 
 +
==External links==
 +
* [http://www.forum-software.org/ Forum Software Reviews]
 +
 
 +
 
 +
[[Category:Appropedia site development]]
 +
[[Category:Appropedia community]]
 +
[[Category:Appropedia WordPress site]]

Latest revision as of 01:53, 15 March 2012

We're talking about installing forums for Appropedia. See the BetterMeans tasks: Install a forum and .

Why?[edit]

A forum:

  • Provides an easy way to engage for the many, many people who find a wiki daunting. We want people to feel comfortable with the wiki, but this can help provide an "on ramp" and provide support during the process.
  • Provides an easy way to have discussion on particular subjects, groups of pages or activities.
  • An easy way to monitor discussions, bring active threads to the top, and make important threads "sticky". (MediaWiki talk pages can be useful for specific articles or projects, but it's hard to get an overview of discussions or follow threads. It's rare for newcomers to post to the Village Pump, and no doubt it's hard for them to make sense of that page. LiquidThreads is one way to try to improve discussions within MediaWiki, but it still has problems.)
  • Helps build a sense of community.

How is this different from other forums?[edit]

There are many forums on sustainability, permaculture, transition etc - it's possible to join those communities and discuss these topics. The Appropedia Forum is different in being:

  • Focused on building a knowledge resource. While topics and tangents may abound, we have a mutual understanding that we want to turn that knowledge into an open knowledge resource - i.e. a set of wiki pages.
  • Open licensed. The terms of contributing are similar to the wiki - your contributions can be reused (for example on the wiki), with attribution, under the CC-by-sa license.
  • A place for Appropedians to get to know each other and inspire each other. This helps keep us inspired to build this living library.
  • Somewhere where we don't have to constantly explain why something belongs on a wiki page - because we're talking with people who "get it".

Desired features[edit]

The central issue is that the forum should support the work of the wiki. It should support users getting their work done - whether that work is Appropedia in general, or the particular project they're working on. The forum should help people in writing articles, inspire them, and encourage people back to the wiki. This means:

  • Creating the right culture, and the right practices
  • Avoiding "chatty" platforms that highlight latest activity without appropriate context (e.g. BuddyPress)

Specific features we want:

  • Cross-login with wiki and (hopefully) the WordPress blog. Should be easy enough with an OpenID backend. (Sounds easy, but we haven't tried yet.)
    • Bonus points for a shared profile, and system messages that work across the sub-sites.
  • Ability to embed forums or forum threads into an Appropedia page. Our Widgets seems the obvious way - we need to test how well this works.
  • Open source - for practical reasons (easier for us to tweak, we can get all features for free) and reasons of principle.
  • Sticky threads - for important announcements & guidelines.
  • Social features: profile, link to a user's own site(s), feed activity to Facebook or elsewhere
  • RSS feeds for each forum and the entire site
  • Widely used & well-supported
  • Easy formatting - strong preference for WYSIWYG. Having one kind of markup on the wiki, and another kind on the forum, would be too much.
  • Allow users to flag spam
  • Voting, so we can find and highlight popular posts.
  • A Q&A Ticket System (task) so that community members can ask questions to the Appropedia community, (e.g. "how can I make my rainwater catchment system more potable in Guatemala?") and the best answers can be marked and compiled.)

Possibly desired features[edit]

  • Replace talk pages on the wiki with forum pages. (Probably not achievable with our current resources.)

We talked about this in early days - there's no obvious way to do this within the site, and LiquidThreads (an attempt to have forum style talk pages) has had mixed results. (LiquidThreads 3.0 is under development by the Wikimedia Foundation, however, so it may be best to wait for that.)

This may actually be a disadvantage, according to one writer about online community, as it means people don't have to revisit the site to check for answers. (My feeling is that people can still forget to come back, and it is a useful feature. --Chriswaterguy 22:21, 7 April 2011 (PDT))

  • Reply by email (not sure if it's possible, and probably not desirable - as above, better to get the user to visit.)
  • Compatible with WordPress and/or MediaWiki

Avoid[edit]

  • Fragmented interfaces that expose content and comments without context (i.e. "chatty" or noisy platforms - activity rather than purpose)

Proposed solutions[edit]

Standalone options[edit]

  • phpBBW - leading forum software
    • proven and highly supported.
    • probably the best feature set in an open source or freeware platform
  • Vanilla Forums[1] - open-source, standards-compliant, customizable discussion forums.
    • easy to use and good documentation
    • clean look
    • seems friendly towards integration - e.g. can be embedded in WordPress
    • not clear that we'd be able to export easily (they seem to be working on an export tool, and even then it depends on the format). However, being open source makes it likely that there'll be an export solution.

The standalone packages seem to be more mature. However, a downside is that they would be yet another platform on top of our MediaWiki + WordPress. This makes it harder to have consistent look and feel, and cross-login.

WordPress options[edit]

  • BBPress[2] - forum software with a twist from the creators of WordPress
    • Can share login with WordPress or be entirely embedded within it
  • Simple:Press[3] the feature rich, completely integrated and fully scalable forum plugin for WordPress
    • Clean looking
    • Plenty of functionality
  • Mingle Forum a Forum Plugin for WordPress that just works
    • Optionally integrates with Mingle

These options may be missed some features compared to the standalone options. However, they should integrate nicely with WordPress, making it easier to have consistent look and feel, and easier to set up and manage cross-login.

Unsuitable[edit]

  • Crabgrass[4] "is a software libre web application designed for social networking, group collaboration and network organizing. Our goal is to create communication tools that are tailored specifically to meet the needs of bottom up grassroots organizing."
    • Seems focused on helping users taking action - which is great.
    • Not mature enough, not very easy to use, by Jason's assessment.
  • WP Symposium is a suite of WordPress plugins to provide social networking features
    • Still in beta - looks promising, but not yet proven. Doesn't describe itself as a forum, but as a kind of online meeting space...
  • DrupalW
    • key advantage is that it would let us do our blog and forum through the same platform.
    • only feasible if we have a committed Drupal person pretty much on call. Drupal is much trickier than WordPress.
    • highly customizable, but we don't need this much power if we just want a simple forum.
  • vBulletin
    • Neither gratis nor libre, trying to become a CMS
  • WagN
    • Requires wagneering to be a forum
  • BuddyPress Social networking in a box.
    • Unfocused, gives sense of activity rather than a sense of purpose.
  • Extension:AWC's Forum (MediaWiki extension)
    • The only reasonably mature option for MediaWiki
    • Appears to be no longer actively developed

Next steps (April 2011)[edit]

Make a shortlist, then install them on our dev site, test and see which we like.

Is anyone interested in doing this?

Policies[edit]

This is a proposed Appropedia policy. You can edit it, or discuss it on the talk page or at the Appropedia policy discussion page.
For now, this should be considered an essay by one or more Appropedians, and not as a policy or guideline.

The forum will operate under these policies:

  • Be friendly and positive: Relevant wiki policies of civility, no personal attacks, not disrupting to make a point...
  • The policy of rigor is less strictly applied, as the forum can be a place for questions and wild ideas. Though if someone is promoting perpetual motion machines or other baseless claims (e.g. the water fuel cell), we may gently point to this policy and explain why we don't give focus to such things; if someone insists on exploring such ideas, we can ask them to take it to the PES wiki, or to come back when they have a working model, or when they want to focus on other issues.
  • All posts are released under the CC-by-sa License, so that relevant content can be easily adapted for use in the wiki (or elsewhere) with attribution. (Attribution in the edit summary is enough when contributing to the wiki? This way it's equivalent in attribution terms to the person posting it directly to the wiki. Or just allow attribution to the forum, with a link to the specific page.)

See also[edit]

External links[edit]