Literature Review for Two-Piece Orthopaedic Crutch
Search Strategy & Terms
[edit | edit source]Key words terms (KWT)
- Open-source hardware
- Distributed manufacturing
- Assistive technology
- Orthopaedic crutch
- Forearm crutch
- 3D printing
- Medical devices
- Sustainable medical technology
- Mechanical testing
- Replicability
- Accessibility
- Joint design
- Adhesive joints
- Bolted joints
- Stress concentration
- ISO 11334
Strategies
Literature was identified primarily through Google Scholar using combinations of the key terms listed above. Additional sources were obtained by following citations within highly relevant publications, searching standards databases (ISO), consulting reports from international organizations (WHO), and reviewing open-source hardware repositories (Open Science Framework and Open Hardware Journal). Preference was given to recent peer-reviewed publications, internationally recognized standards, and foundational papers in distributed manufacturing and open-source hardware.
What is the Topic?
[edit | edit source]This project investigates methods for improving the accessibility, manufacturability, and replicability of open-source forearm crutches through redesign of the structural joint architecture.
Traditional assistive devices frequently rely on commercially manufactured hardware and centralized supply chains, limiting accessibility in many low-resource settings. Open-source distributed manufacturing has emerged as an alternative approach that allows assistive devices to be fabricated locally using widely available 3D printers and materials.
This work specifically examines whether replacing conventional screw-fastened joints with hardware-minimized fastening systems—including adhesive interference-fit joints and threaded collet compression joints—can maintain or improve mechanical performance while simplifying assembly and reducing dependence on externally sourced components.
Theoretical Framework
[edit | edit source]The work evaluates both engineering performance and broader design considerations such as accessibility, repairability, manufacturability, modularity, and sustainability.
Significance and Importance
[edit | edit source]More than 2.5 billion people worldwide require at least one assistive technology, with this number expected to exceed 3.5 billion by 2050 due to aging populations and increasing prevalence of chronic disease.
Despite growing need, access to assistive technology remains highly unequal. Many individuals lack access because of:
- Cost
- Geographic isolation
- Limited healthcare infrastructure
- Dependence on centralized manufacturing
- Supply chain disruptions
- Limited availability of replacement parts
Open-source distributed manufacturing offers an opportunity to fabricate assistive devices locally using affordable desktop 3D printers.
However, successful fabrication alone does not guarantee successful implementation. Devices should also be:
- Easy to assemble
- Easy to repair
- Highly replicable
- Independent of specialized hardware
- Mechanically reliable
This research addresses these practical implementation barriers.
Current State of the Art
[edit | edit source]Development of open-source assistive technologies has progressed considerably over the past decade. Recent open-source forearm crutch designs have demonstrated mechanical performance approaching commercial products while substantially reducing manufacturing costs.
Current limitations include:
- Reliance on screws and standardized hardware
- Complex assembly procedures
- Localized stress concentrations around fasteners
- Reduced accessibility in regions where hardware availability is limited
Little research has evaluated alternative fastening strategies that simultaneously improve structural performance and simplify distributed manufacturing.
Relevant Stakeholders
[edit | edit source]- Individuals requiring mobility aids
- People with disabilities
- Elderly populations
- Rehabilitation clinics
- Hospitals
- Prosthetics and orthotics clinics
- Humanitarian organizations
- NGOs
- Community fabrication laboratories (FabLabs)
- Makerspaces
- Healthcare providers
- Engineers
- Designers
- Open-source hardware developers
- Researchers
- Manufacturers
- Policy makers
- International health organizations (WHO)
Applicability and Context
[edit | edit source]This research is particularly applicable to:
- Low-resource healthcare systems
- Rural and remote communities
- Humanitarian aid settings
- Disaster relief
- Developing countries
- Community makerspaces
- Distributed manufacturing networks
- Educational institutions
- Open-source hardware communities
Literature
[edit | edit source]Global Need for Assistive Technology
[edit | edit source]WHO Global Report on Assistive Technology
[edit | edit source]Source: https://iris.who.int/server/api/core/bitstreams/17a1cbf6-be26-466c-9fca-ab80eeb2d192/content
- Establishes the worldwide need for assistive technologies.
- Reports that over 2.5 billion people currently require at least one assistive product, with demand expected to exceed 3.5 billion by 2050.
- Highlights large disparities in access between countries (approximately 3–90% coverage).
- Identifies barriers including affordability, infrastructure, trained personnel, and supply chains.
- Provides justification for developing lower-cost, locally manufacturable assistive devices.
- Serves as the primary motivation for improving accessibility through distributed manufacturing.
Open-Source Forearm Crutch Development
[edit | edit source]Open-source 3D Printable Forearm Crutch
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/389172785_Open-source_3D_printable_forearm_crutch/link/67b7821596e7fb48b9c8f2a0/download
- Introduces the original open-source forearm crutch design.
- Demonstrates that a 3D printed forearm crutch can satisfy structural requirements while remaining affordable.
- Uses modular screw-fastened joints.
- Establishes the baseline design modified in the current study.
- Discusses distributed manufacturing as an approach for increasing accessibility.
- Identifies opportunities for future design improvements.
Recent Open-Source Forearm Crutch Article (2026)
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.02.13.26345756v2
- Provides the newest iteration of the open-source forearm crutch.
- Demonstrates mechanical validation of the design.
- Compares performance with commercial devices.
- Reinforces the feasibility of distributed manufacturing.
- Continues to rely on hardware-fastened joints.
- Leaves opportunities to investigate alternative fastening systems.
Supplementary Material
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.64898/2026.02.13.26345756v2.supplementary-material
- Contains detailed testing procedures.
- Includes additional mechanical data.
- Provides supplementary figures and analyses.
- Useful for reproducing experimental methods.
- Assists interpretation of reported mechanical performance.
Open Science Framework Repository
[edit | edit source]Source: https://osf.io/n8m5y/files/osfstorage
- Contains complete CAD files.
- Includes printable STL and STEP models.
- Provides documentation for distributed manufacturing.
- Demonstrates open-source design transparency.
- Serves as the starting point for redesigning the crutch joints in this study.
General Open-Source Distributed Manufacturing
[edit | edit source]Source: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10668-012-9337-9
- Introduces distributed manufacturing concepts.
- Explains environmental and economic benefits of localized production.
- Discusses sustainability advantages.
- Supports reducing dependence on centralized manufacturing.
- Demonstrates how distributed manufacturing enables community-based production.
What is the Source of Open Source?
[edit | edit source]Source: https://ojs.lib.uwo.ca/index.php/openhardware/article/view/17830
- Explains the origins and philosophy of open-source hardware.
- Reviews development of the open hardware movement.
- Discusses transparency and collaborative design.
- Explains why open hardware promotes innovation and accessibility.
- Provides background for distributed manufacturing.
Distributed Manufacturing of Open Hardware
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.law.nyu.edu/sites/default/files/DistributedManufacturingofOpenHardware.p
- Reviews distributed manufacturing of open hardware.
- Discusses intellectual property considerations.
- Explains logistical benefits of local manufacturing.
- Highlights challenges including quality assurance and regulatory compliance.
- Discusses implementation in healthcare technologies.
Identifying Factors Affecting the Replicability of Open-Source Hardware Designs
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/proceedings-of-the-design-society/article/identifying-the-factors-affecting-the-replicability-of-open-source-hardware-designs/02509F521214AFF0124B005C348875C7
- Defines replicability in open-source hardware.
- Identifies factors that influence successful reproduction.
- Highlights documentation quality as a major contributor.
- Discusses manufacturing complexity.
- Supports minimizing specialized hardware.
- Suggests design simplification improves accessibility.
Designing for Replicability
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/design-science/article/designing-for-replicability-a-qualitative-empirical-study-on-the-replication-of-opensource-machine-tools/B75B173A1D57431A53974CB79A4DE3F5
- Investigates replicability in distributed manufacturing.
- Focuses on low-resource implementation.
- Demonstrates importance of reducing assembly complexity.
- Identifies documentation and modularity as key factors.
- Supports hardware-minimized design philosophy.
3D Printing Methodology
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0957415813001153
- Reviews additive manufacturing workflows.
- Discusses optimization of printing parameters.
- Summarizes advantages of fused filament fabrication.
- Provides methodology applicable to medical devices.
- Supports manufacturing decisions used in this project.
Stress Concentration Around Bolt Holes
[edit | edit source]Source: https://soar.wichita.edu/server/api/core/bitstreams/63f29faa-f537-4cf3-86a8-3258861fbe95/content
- Investigates stress concentrations surrounding bolted holes.
- Demonstrates how holes create localized stress amplification.
- Explains crack initiation mechanisms.
- Supports elimination of screw holes in redesigned joints.
- Provides theoretical basis for structural reinforcement.
Peterson's Stress Concentration Factors
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287239966_Peterson's_Stress_Concentration_Factors_Third_Edition
- Standard reference for stress concentration theory.
- Quantifies stress increases around geometric discontinuities.
- Supports theoretical discussion of screw-hole removal.
- Useful reference for interpreting failure locations.
- Provides equations and correction factors for stress analysis.
Bolted Joints vs Bonded Joints
[edit | edit source]Source: https://eprintspublications.npl.co.uk/2130/1/MATC65.pdf
- Compares adhesive and mechanical fastening methods.
- Reviews advantages and disadvantages of each approach.
- Discusses load transfer characteristics.
- Compares common failure mechanisms.
- Supports evaluation of the adhesive interference-fit joint.
ISO 11334
[edit | edit source]Source: https://www.iso.org/standard/36054.html
- Specifies testing requirements for elbow crutches.
- Defines static loading procedures.
- Establishes performance criteria for structural evaluation.
- Enables standardized comparison between crutch designs.
- Forms the basis of the experimental methodology.
Topics Requiring Additional Literature
[edit | edit source]- Adhesive bonding between PETG and wood
- Mechanical properties of PETG
- Threaded collet fastening systems
- Compression-based load transfer mechanisms
- Fatigue testing of mobility aids
- Repairability metrics for open-source hardware
- Life-cycle assessment of distributed manufacturing
- Economic comparison of locally manufactured versus commercial assistive devices
- Human factors and usability of forearm crutches
| Authors | |
|---|---|
| License | CC-BY-SA-4.0 |
| Cite as | Kklass2 (2026). "Literature Review for Two-Piece Orthopaedic Crutch". Appropedia. Retrieved July 14, 2026. |