Evaluation of Innovation and Technological Novelty in Startups Applying for Government Support
Scope
[edit | edit source]More than 100 startup applications across multiple sectors, including industrial technology, energy, finance, retail, healthcare, and other industries.
Objective
[edit | edit source]To assess the innovation component and technological novelty of startups applying for grants and other forms of government support. The key challenge was to establish a consistent evaluation approach across a broad range of industries, within limited timeframes and without access to specialized technical experts in every field.
Methodology
[edit | edit source]The evaluation framework covered three main dimensions:
Innovation
Whether a project introduced a fundamentally new approach to an existing problem or improved existing technologies using international best practices not yet available in the domestic market
Technology Readiness Level (TRL)
Assessment based on an internal TRL framework, supported by mandatory documentation submitted by applicants and publicly available evidence of pilots, implementations, and other project milestones.
Open-source software
For software and hardware-software solutions, the use of open-source code and registration of modified software components in relevant government registries were considered positive factors.
For the assessment of technological novelty, a content-analysis approach was used. Generative AI supported the initial processing of technical documentation and extraction of key semantic concepts, which were subsequently used to search for relevant scientific publications, patents, and industrial implementation cases.
My Contribution
[edit | edit source]As an analyst, I contributed to the development and application of the innovation assessment methodology in collaboration with colleagues. I processed technical documentation using generative AI, identified relevant search terms, and conducted comparative research across scientific publications, patent databases, and industrial cases.
I also assessed supporting evidence of technological readiness and reviewed the use of open-source software and relevant state registrations as part of the overall evaluation.
Results
[edit | edit source]- Evaluated more than 100 startup applications.
- Approximately 16% of projects received a positive assessment.
- Applied a structured approach to preliminary innovation assessment across multiple technological domains.
- Identified a key methodological limitation: establishing technological novelty does not automatically demonstrate technical viability, practical applicability, or commercial potential.
| Authors | Iana Kliui |
|---|---|
| License | CC-BY-SA-4.0 |
| Cite as | Iana Kliui (2026). "Evaluation of Innovation and Technological Novelty in Startups Applying for Government Support". Appropedia. Retrieved November 18, 2026. |