Editing Pressure Retarded Osmosis (PRO) Education

[[File:IMG 0886.jpg|thumb]]

{{Project data
| authors = User:Leabethmae88, Chandler Ichikawa, Lianna Winkler-Prins, Brian Wallace, Kevin Kopp, Sarah Morton
| completed = 2013
}}

[[File:IMG 0424 - Version 2.JPG|thumb]]

To increase awareness of pressure retarded osmosis (PRO) as a potential source of renewable energy, an interactive device that demonstrates power generation and osmosis through a semipermeable membrane was developed by a group of students from Cal Poly Humboldt's Section of Society of Women Engineers. The lab-scale device was fabricated using a 3D printer, which constructs three-dimensional solid objects from digital models. This method of construction allows for replication of the device; requiring only the digital plans, a 3D printer, and the thermoplastic used by the printer.

== Project Objective ==

[[File:Screen Shot 2013-07-03 at 8.12.25 PM.png|thumb|Graphic Credit: Brian Wallace]]

The project objective is to build a community of engineers, scientists and educators which utilizes the PRO device and contributes to the community by providing feedback and sharing their findings. SWE will help build this community by making the device available and promoting the system to aforementioned interest groups.

== Background ==

Pressure retarded osmosis (PRO) is an emerging technology in which power is generated by the interaction between saltwater and freshwater through membrane permeation. During PRO, a low-salinity (feed) solution is drawn through a membrane into a pressurized, high-salinity (draw) solution (Figure 1) Power can then be generated by releasing the pressure through a turbine.

Water flux (Jw) is dependent on the membrane's water permeability coefficient (A), the osmotic pressure differential (π), and the hydraulic pressure differential (P). The power generated per unit membrane area (W), i.e. the power density, is dependent on flux and the hydraulic pressure difference across the membrane.

π, the osmotic pressure differential, is equal to the magnitude of the hydraulic pressure differential (P) that would prevent net transport of water across the membrane. OLI Stream Analyzer 2.0 software (OLI Systems, Inc., Morris Plains, NJ) gives the following relationship between osmotic pressure (in kPa) and molarity for sodium chloride:

Concentration polarization (CP) is a phenomenon that describes the accumulation or depletion of solutes near the interface of a membrane [1]. Two types of CP occur in a PRO configuration: dilutive external CP and concentrative internal CP. In this investigation, predicted flux and power density values will be compared to experimental values. Due to CP, an increase in osmotic pressure differential is not expected to cause a proportionate increase in flux and power density.

== Description of Device ==

The PRO device has two 7"x7"x2" chambers that sit side by side and are separated by a semipermeable membrane. Both chambers have two ¼" female NPT threaded hexes in their ceilings. The chambers are clamped together by 12 screw/hex nut/washer assemblies, with two 1/16"-thick nitrile gaskets and two membrane support screens in between (Figure 3). One chamber is non-pressurized and holds the feed solution; the other chamber is pressurized and holds the draw solution. The pressurized chamber has a 12"-long clear PVC pipe threaded into its ceiling, with an 80 mL reservoir above. Water from the feed solution flows into the draw solution, forcing water to rise in the pipe and store in the reservoir. The reservoir has a ¼" NPT plastic valve threaded into one end of its floor, which releases fluid onto a water wheel below. Fluid from the wheel is captured in a funnel, which drains back into the draw solution.

[[File:Imageburst.jpg|thumb|Graphic Credit: Lianna Winkler-Prins and Brian Wallace|alt=]]

== Construction ==

SolidWorks 2012 was used to draw 3D plans for the main chambers, reservoir, water wheel, funnel, and mesh screens. The objects were printed by a uPrint SE Plus 3D Printer (Stratasys, Minneapolis, MN), available at Cal Poly Humboldt, using ABS thermoplastic (Figure 4).

Two coats of fiberglass resin were painted on all 3D printed objects to reduce leakage of the device. ¼" NPT male and female threading devices were used to better define the printed threading on the chambers and reservoir and on the funnel, respectively. For each gasket, the outer perimeters of the main chamber and mesh screen were drawn onto 1/16"-thick nitrile and cut with an exacto knife. Twelve holes were made for the clamping assemblies using a hammer and a steel punch.

<!-- Here is a sample gallery. -->
<gallery caption="PRO apparatus pictures" |left="">
File:Photo (3).JPG|Chamber being printed via 3D uPrint Plus Photo Credit: Leabeth Peterson
File:IMG 0863.JPG|Chambers put together Photo Credit: Leabeth Peterson
File:IMG 0886.jpg|Construction of apparatus minus the water wheel Photo Credit: Leabeth Peterson
</gallery>

== Experimental Design ==

Membranes: For the experiments a flat-sheet cellulose triacetate (CTA) forward osmosis membrane was used from Hydration Technology Innovations in Albany, OR. This particular membrane has been determined to be the best available membrane in FO applications [2].

Solution Chemistries: Certified NaCl from EM Science Industries and JT Baker Industries was used to prepare the various feed and draw solutions. The draw solution concentrations were varied in order to provide a range of values for flux and power density. Draw solution concentrations used were 35, 70, 150, and 300 g/L, and DI water was used for all feed solutions. OLI Stream Analyzer 2.0 (Eqn. 4) was used to calculate the osmotic pressure differential for each setup (Table 4).

=== Criteria and Constraints ===

Table 1. Criteria and constraints determined for the design of the PRO device.

{| class="wikitable"
! Criteria
! Constraints
|-
| Easy to Use
| Can be assembled by young adults.
|-
| Portable
| Can be transported easily.
|-
| Durable
| Design life of two years, with appropriate maintenance.
|-
| Watertight
| Should not leak more than 20 mL per hour.
|-
| Self-Contained
| Water cycles within the device.
|-
| Sufficient flow to spin wheel
| Adequate membrane area and flux.
|-
| Size
| No printed piece may exceed 8"x8"x6".
|-
| Cost
| Design 3D parts to minimize cost.
|}

== PRO Experiments ==

For the experiments the feed chamber was filled with DI water and the draw chamber with the NaCl solution. The time for the rising water column to reach the reservoir was measured. Also, the volume of the water collected in the reservoir for the 10 minutes following was measured.

<!-- Here is a sample gallery. -->
<gallery caption="PRO apparatus pictures" |left="">
File:IMG 0913.JPG|Using the apparatus
File:IMG 0917.JPG|Tightening the bolts on the apparatus
</gallery>

== Future Work ==

Outreach possibilities the HSU section of SWE hopes to pursue include demonstrations for:

* K-12 classrooms
* Associated Students Programs
* Local Girl Scouts on Girl Scout Day
* HSU Engineering social events

'''''Those interested in obtaining the digital plans for education and research purposes may submit a proposal of their intentions at our website <font color="Black">[[proeducationhsu.org]]'''''

<!--This is where you can describe what already exists, what is needed, etc. You may want to include inline references.<ref>You can use the ref code to include inline references. See [[Help:Footnotes]] for more.</ref>-->

<!--To make bullets use the asterisk:

* Like this
* and like this
** and two for the next indent
* and back to one...-->

<!--== Project goals ==
Describe project goals here.
To make a numbered list use the pound sign:

# Like this
# and like this
# See [[Help:Contents]] for more formatting code.-->

<!--== Costs ==

You may describe your costs here.

{| class="wikitable"
! header 1
! header 2
! header 3
|-
| row 1, cell 1
| row 1, cell 2
| row 1, cell 3
|-
| row 2, cell 1
| row 2, cell 2
| row 2, cell 3
|}

-->
<!--See [[Help:Tables]] and [[Help:Table examples]] for more.>

== Discussion ==

Coming Soon.

<!--== Conclusions ==

Your conclusions.-->

== References ==

[1] Achilli, A., Cath, T. Y., and Childress, A.E. (2009). "Power Generation With Pressure Retarded Osmosis: An Experimental and Theoretical Investigation." Journal of Membrane Science, 343, 42-52.

[2] Achilli, A., and Childress, A.E. (2010). "Pressure Retarded Osmosis: From the Vision of Sidney Loeb to the First Prototype Installation." Desalination, 261, 205-211.

[3] Anastasio, D. and McCutcheon, J. R. (2013). "Using Forward Osmosis to Teach Mass Transfer Fundamentals to Undergraduate Chemical Engineering Students." Desalination, 312, 10-18.

[4] Cath, T. Y., Childress, A. E., and Elimelech, M. (2006). "Forward Osmosis: Principles, Applications, and Recent Developments." Journal of Membrane Science, 281, 70-87.

[5] McCutcheon, M. E., and Elimelech, M. (2006). "Influence of Concentrative and Dilutive Internal Concentration Polarization on Flux Behavior in Forward Osmosis." Journal of Membrane Science, 284, 237-247.

== Contact details ==

Section of Society of Women Engineers at Cal Poly Humboldt

* President Contact Information:
** Leabeth Peterson
*** lmp56@humboldt.edu
*** swe@humboldt.edu
* Vice-President Contact Information:
** Chandler Ichikawa
*** chi4@humboldt.edu
* Contributing members in PRO project:
** Lianna Winkler-Prins
*** lw76@humboldt.edu
** Brian Wallace
*** bmw56@humboldt.edu
** Kevin Kopp
*** kbk7@humboldt.edu
** Sarah Morton
*** sdm82@humboldt.edu

<font color="Red">'''Those interested in obtaining the digital plans for education and research purposes may submit a proposal of their intentions at our website <font color="Black">[[proeducationhsu.org]]'''

== Related Ideas and Pages ==

[[Renewable Energy]] [[Cal Poly Humboldt]]
[[Renewable Energy Dictionary]] [[Reverse osmosis]] [[Desalination plants (original)]]

{{Page data
| keywords = 3d printing, education, renewable, pressure retarded osmosis, thermoplastic, 3d printer
| sdg = SDG04 Quality education, SDG07 Affordable and clean energy, SDG11 Sustainable cities and communities
| published = 2013
| organizations = Society of Women Engineers, Cal Poly Humboldt
| license = CC-BY-SA-3.0
| language = en
}}

[[Category:Education]]
[[Category:OSAT 3D-Printable Designs]]
[[Category:3D printing]]
[[Category:3d printing]]