Appropedia needs your support - Please Donate Today
Comparison of electric motors
This article deals about the differences between electric motors and the most appropriate forms for particular tasks.
Basic design of electric motors
Types include :
- alternating current (AC) motors
- direct current (DC) motors
- and universal motors.
An AC electric motor will not run when supplied with DC current, and a DC motor will not run on AC current; a AC/DC motor will however run on either AC or DC current.
- AC electric motors: Induction motor (squirrel cage rotor), Induction motor (slip ring rotor), Induction motor (solid core rotor), Shaded pole motor, ...
- DC electric motors: Pancake DC motor, Brushed DC electric motor, Brushless DC electric motor, Stepper DC motor, ...
- AC/DC motors: Universal motor
AC & DC motors
One of the main differentiation we can make between the engines is on whether they use AC or DC power. Surprisingly however, in practice, this doesn't really matter that much since the engines are so different on regards to weight, efficiency, durability, ... There for example isn't a "AC" version of the Brushed or Brushless DC engine, ... Instead, each engine is different, and is most suitable to a specific type of application.
1, 2 or 3-phases
Another differentiation can be made on regards to 1, 2 and 3-phase engines. In general, most engines can be made in 1, 2, and 3-phases, so the phases refer to the subtype of engine, and not an engine category on its own.
The way on how the engine is different lies in how the electromagnets (poles) are made. With 1 phase engines, there is 1 wire making the poles (arranged in series). With 2 phase, there are 2 wires, and with 3-phase, there are 3.
The difference lies in that the rotation speed of the engine (and hence the power output) can be regulated to a greater extent (although this also depends on the type of electric engine used). With 3-phase engines, it may be possible to eliminate a gearbox in some situations. The same can however also be done with a controller (ie with Brushless DC engines), pulse width modulator (ie with Pancake DC, ...), or variable frequency source.
Another difference is that the more phases, the greater the total power output can be (more powerful engines are possible), the more power the engine has compared to its size/weight, and (possibly) the greater the efficiency. The tradeoff is however the increased complexity of building and increased cost (the latter depending again on the type of engine chosen).
Finally, a last benefit is reduced power loss over electricity lines (connected to the engine). The latter however is only of importance if the power source is very far away.
In general, we must see the required power output of the engine, the application where the engine is to be used for, and the type of engine used in the first place; only then can we assess whether it's useful to have 2/3-phases or not.
Requirement of clutch + gearbox
Some electric motors have, due to their design (windings, ...) no need for gears. Instead, they change their electrical output automatically, themselves. Other electric motors do benefit from gears, and thus require a more complex setup. The addition of gears also adds to the weight of the entire system.
- Clutch/gearbox required --> ?
- No clutch/gearbox required --> variable frequency drive or Adjustable speed drive, or ...
Most useful of motor depending on the application
- DC brushed motor (or DC pancake motor): useful for domestic applications (ie powering washing machines, dishwashers)
- AC induction motor (squirrel cage rotor, class A, single phase): useful for vehicles, ...
- AC induction motor (squirrel cage rotor, class A, three phase): useful for vehicles not requiring a gearbox, pumps, other appliances without gearbox, ...
Why no brushless DC engine, or other types ? Because the brushless DC engine can be replaced by the AC induction motor. The fewer types of engines, the easier people can be trained the theory of the engines, as well as the skill of building them. Also, the AC induction motor can be built at lower cost, and is more durable. The only disadvantage is the AC power supply; given that most vehicles, ... use DC power (lead-acid battery), a inverter is needed.
- AT brushed electric motor/alternator
- Comparison of motors: compares the efficiencies of some electric motors