Difference between revisions of "No derivatives clause"

From Appropedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with 'The '''No Derivative Works''' clause (commonly referred to as '''No Derivatives''') in some Creative Commons licenses allows reuse while not allowing any modification to …')
 
m
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
The '''No Derivative Works''' clause (commonly referred to as '''No Derivatives''') in some [[Creative Commons]] [[licenses]] allows reuse while not allowing any modification to the work.  
 
The '''No Derivative Works''' clause (commonly referred to as '''No Derivatives''') in some [[Creative Commons]] [[licenses]] allows reuse while not allowing any modification to the work.  
  
This restricts one of the [[Four Freedoms]]{{fact}} and such a license is not considered an [[open license]] or free license ([[free (libre)]]as in freedom of speech).
+
This restricts one of the [[Four Freedoms]]{{fact}} and such a license is not considered an [[open license]] (a.k.a. free license - "free" as in freedom of speech).
  
 
Such licenses aim to protect the work, but from what?
 
Such licenses aim to protect the work, but from what?
Line 7: Line 7:
 
* misunderstandings, people thinking that the altered work is actually the work of the original author.
 
* misunderstandings, people thinking that the altered work is actually the work of the original author.
  
However this clause also greatly restricts the usefulness of the work. Wikipedia, Appropedia and other successful [[wiki]] projects have shown the value of a community of editors (or a single enthusiastic editor being able to modify an article, and add their own particular knowledge.  
+
However this clause also greatly restricts the usefulness of the work. Wikipedia, Appropedia and other successful [[wiki]] projects have shown the value of a community of editors, or of a single enthusiastic editor being able to modify an article, and add their own particular knowledge.  
  
 
Note that work under a no derivatives license '''cannot be used on Appropedia''' (other than in exceptional and temporary cases as part of the [[Appropedia:Open access pages|Open access pages]] policy, intended to serve a need until actual open content is made available).
 
Note that work under a no derivatives license '''cannot be used on Appropedia''' (other than in exceptional and temporary cases as part of the [[Appropedia:Open access pages|Open access pages]] policy, intended to serve a need until actual open content is made available).

Latest revision as of 13:11, 17 July 2012

The No Derivative Works clause (commonly referred to as No Derivatives) in some Creative Commons licenses allows reuse while not allowing any modification to the work.

This restricts one of the Four Freedoms[verification needed] and such a license is not considered an open license (a.k.a. free license - "free" as in freedom of speech).

Such licenses aim to protect the work, but from what?

  • being altered in ways that might lead to harm being done
  • misunderstandings, people thinking that the altered work is actually the work of the original author.

However this clause also greatly restricts the usefulness of the work. Wikipedia, Appropedia and other successful wiki projects have shown the value of a community of editors, or of a single enthusiastic editor being able to modify an article, and add their own particular knowledge.

Note that work under a no derivatives license cannot be used on Appropedia (other than in exceptional and temporary cases as part of the Open access pages policy, intended to serve a need until actual open content is made available).

See also[edit | edit source]