No edit summary
(35 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 5: Line 5:
The purpose of this page is to discuss comments/concerns about implementing infoboxes on Appropedia pages.
The purpose of this page is to discuss comments/concerns about implementing infoboxes on Appropedia pages.


== Comments ==
== Comments & Concerns ==


* [["Backpack" Snap-fit Clips]]  
* [["Backpack" Snap-fit Clips]]  
Line 13: Line 13:
* [[2 Liter Winnower]]
* [[2 Liter Winnower]]
** EDITS: added status, added keywords, updated intended use, changed to not made (did not find evidence of model/prototype, just design)
** EDITS: added status, added keywords, updated intended use, changed to not made (did not find evidence of model/prototype, just design)
* [[3-D printable open source dual axis gimbal system for optoelectronic measurements]]
** EDITS: changed description, added keywords to inbox
** CONCERN: should status be "verified" or "verified technology" (or something else)
* [[3-D printable photovoltaic module spacer]]
** EDITS: added status, added keywords, shortened description
* [[3-D printable solar charger]]
** EDITS: added keywords, added status, added more SDGS
** CONCERN: intended use --> development and industry work but this could be used at home as well (not really hobbyism though)--> added "individual use" (open to changing--> maybe personal device?)
* [[3-D Printing Solar Photovoltaic Racking in Developing World]]
** EDITS: added status, shortened description, added to intended use
*[[3D Print Speculum]]
** EDITS: added status, shortened description, added to intended use, added keywords
*[[3D Printable Cider Press]]
**EDITS: added status, changed description, changed intended use, added keywords, changed to 'made'
'''To expedite editing, I will no longer list simple edits made, only concerns...'''
*[[Bike rack]]
** Concern: this page does not have any design files, images, or design descriptions, so I listed the project status as an "Idea" rather than "Design" (no evidence of a design)
*[[Clamps with gearing system]]
** Concern: I removed the verified status due to lack of evidence
*[[Dust Mask]]
** Concern: This page has the following status levels listed: designed, prototyped, deployed, modeled, verified. I do not see evidence of anything past prototyped, so I removed deployed and verified. (Open to changing this back).
*[[GPS Belt Clip]], [[Improved GPS Belt Clip]], [[Ice Scraper]], [[Modified Spork Design]], [[Open sustainability]]
** Concern: Unsure if any SDGs relate
*[[Micro Lathe]]
** I removed verified status.
*[[Minnow Trap]]
**Design files not present/ no evidence of a prototype. There is a CAD image, but no file. I removed prototype status and listed as open design; however, should I change to idea?
*[[Micro Lathe]]
** There are two pages from the same creator; I edited the one with more information... should we delete the other?
** Resolved: Similar to the modular hand held arm pages (discussed below), I included a link to the more complete design in the preliminary design's description
*[[Modular Coral Regrowth Post]]
** All of the image/file links are broken :/
** Can we contact creator? Seems like a very interesting and important design!
** For now, I do not have a development stage listed.
*[[Modular hand held arm with "Backsaver" grip attachment and "Leaf Claws"]] & [[Modular hand held arm with "Backsaver" grip attachment"]]
** I believe the latter was a preliminary version of the former... same creator and same description; however, the first page includes design files, images, and more info
** On the preliminary page, I included a link to the more complete page in the description. I filled in the other categories to be the same as the more complete page, but perhaps I should have left them blank?
*[[Spoon Fork Knife]]
** I find the wording used to be prejudiced of developing countries. Not all developing countries only eat with their hands.
*[[Starter Handle]]
** Design files/prototype pictures are not included, so I'm giving "idea" status
*[[Umbilical Cord Clip]] and [[Umbilical Cord Clamp]]
** Same picture used but different creator...
== General Comments ==
* I have focused on editing/adding to description, intended use, keywords, development stage, made, and SDGs.
* Intended uses that I added: agriculture, transportation, medical, shelter, energy, cooking
* It is helpful to have a concise description
** should be an edited down version of the abstract rather than the entire abstract
* There should be proof of prototype existence (ie photo of print) to be given prototype status
* There should be proof of outside verification and/or data from creator's tests to be given verified status
* '''Made-Independently'''
** To clarify, this means that someone other than the creator made the technology '''using the creator's design'''
** Most of the pages have been incorrect
** We should consider adding definition on form page.
* SDG category
** I noticed there was a change in the form-- you can now select goals from drop down menu (ie "SDG01")
** Prior to this, I had been writing goals in longhand (ie "Sustainable Development Goal 1")
** Will this be an issue in distinguishing all of the projects that fall under specific goals?
** Issue tested: The SDG09 category does not add to the Sustainable Development Goal 9 project list; however, SDG11 adds to the Sustainable Development Goal 11 project list

Revision as of 21:02, 22 July 2020


Description

The purpose of this page is to discuss comments/concerns about implementing infoboxes on Appropedia pages.

Comments & Concerns

  • 2 Liter Winnower
    • EDITS: added status, added keywords, updated intended use, changed to not made (did not find evidence of model/prototype, just design)
  • 3-D printable solar charger
    • EDITS: added keywords, added status, added more SDGS
    • CONCERN: intended use --> development and industry work but this could be used at home as well (not really hobbyism though)--> added "individual use" (open to changing--> maybe personal device?)
  • 3D Print Speculum
    • EDITS: added status, shortened description, added to intended use, added keywords
  • 3D Printable Cider Press
    • EDITS: added status, changed description, changed intended use, added keywords, changed to 'made'

To expedite editing, I will no longer list simple edits made, only concerns...

  • Bike rack
    • Concern: this page does not have any design files, images, or design descriptions, so I listed the project status as an "Idea" rather than "Design" (no evidence of a design)
  • Dust Mask
    • Concern: This page has the following status levels listed: designed, prototyped, deployed, modeled, verified. I do not see evidence of anything past prototyped, so I removed deployed and verified. (Open to changing this back).
  • Minnow Trap
    • Design files not present/ no evidence of a prototype. There is a CAD image, but no file. I removed prototype status and listed as open design; however, should I change to idea?
  • Micro Lathe
    • There are two pages from the same creator; I edited the one with more information... should we delete the other?
    • Resolved: Similar to the modular hand held arm pages (discussed below), I included a link to the more complete design in the preliminary design's description
  • Modular Coral Regrowth Post
    • All of the image/file links are broken :/
    • Can we contact creator? Seems like a very interesting and important design!
    • For now, I do not have a development stage listed.
  • Spoon Fork Knife
    • I find the wording used to be prejudiced of developing countries. Not all developing countries only eat with their hands.
  • Starter Handle
    • Design files/prototype pictures are not included, so I'm giving "idea" status

General Comments

  • I have focused on editing/adding to description, intended use, keywords, development stage, made, and SDGs.
  • Intended uses that I added: agriculture, transportation, medical, shelter, energy, cooking
  • It is helpful to have a concise description
    • should be an edited down version of the abstract rather than the entire abstract
  • There should be proof of prototype existence (ie photo of print) to be given prototype status
  • There should be proof of outside verification and/or data from creator's tests to be given verified status
  • Made-Independently
    • To clarify, this means that someone other than the creator made the technology using the creator's design
    • Most of the pages have been incorrect
    • We should consider adding definition on form page.
  • SDG category
    • I noticed there was a change in the form-- you can now select goals from drop down menu (ie "SDG01")
    • Prior to this, I had been writing goals in longhand (ie "Sustainable Development Goal 1")
    • Will this be an issue in distinguishing all of the projects that fall under specific goals?
    • Issue tested: The SDG09 category does not add to the Sustainable Development Goal 9 project list; however, SDG11 adds to the Sustainable Development Goal 11 project list
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.