Get our free book (in Spanish or English) on rainwater now - To Catch the Rain.

Difference between revisions of "Dams"

From Appropedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(#redirect Category:Dams )
 
(Pros and cons (mostly cons) of dams)
Line 1: Line 1:
#redirect [[:Category:Dams ]]
+
{{Wikipedia}}
 +
Dams have played an important role in supplying and storing water, particularly for large communities such as cities, and also for agriculture. However, they are now widely recognized as having many serious negative environmental, social and [[public health]] impacts:
 +
*Trapping of sediment - this reduces sediment and nutrient flow down the river, with effects as far away as declining offshore fish stocks (as is reported with the {{WP|Three Gorges Dam}} in China. This sediment also fills the dam, reducing its capacity.
 +
*interference with ecosystems including fish stocks. This is particularly the case where indigenous species are adapted to a cycle of wet and dry, as in Australian rivers - dams disrupt the cycle, and indigenous species lose their survival advantage over introduced species.
 +
*Traditional farmers whose farming patterns depend on the natural cycle of the river can suffer. For example, in the Nile Valley, traditional farmers received irrigation and natural fertilizer the annual floods, but after they dam was built, they could not get the water without paying,{{fact}}, and had to pay for fertilizer instead of receiving free nutrient-rich sediment deposited by the flood.
 +
*Displacement of local people. Activists (including {{WP|Arundhati Roy}}{{fact}})alleged that poor people are frequently thrown off their land with no choice, and little or no compensation.
 +
*Diseases spread by water may be an issue. For example the use of the {{WP|Aswan Dam}} for agriculture removed the traditional dry period, allowing snails to survive, spread, and act as intermediate hosts{{fact}} for the {{WP|schistosomiasis}} pathogen, causing serious health problems to agricultural workers and others who had contact with the water.
 +
 
 +
These factors, and the fact that most suitable sites for dams have been dammed already, mean that other means of [[water supply]] are generally preferred. In some cases, old dams may actually be removed, or at least made to allow more water through (referred to as an {{WP|environmental flow}}).
 +
 
 +
Of course, many factors must be considered, and the needs of the community may be such that a dam is required. In this case, design is very important:
 +
*Size no larger than necessary. This can be helped by emphasizing water efficiency in the community.
 +
*Use of {{WP|fish ladder}} to minimize ecological impact. These should be designed for the local species.
 +
 
 +
[[Category:Water supply]]

Revision as of 05:53, 11 February 2007

NOTE: This tag is deprecated - please use an interwiki link section instead. Discuss.
Information on Dams can be found at Wikipedia. What's this?

Dams have played an important role in supplying and storing water, particularly for large communities such as cities, and also for agriculture. However, they are now widely recognized as having many serious negative environmental, social and public health impacts:

  • Trapping of sediment - this reduces sediment and nutrient flow down the river, with effects as far away as declining offshore fish stocks (as is reported with the Three Gorges DamDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD. in China. This sediment also fills the dam, reducing its capacity.
  • interference with ecosystems including fish stocks. This is particularly the case where indigenous species are adapted to a cycle of wet and dry, as in Australian rivers - dams disrupt the cycle, and indigenous species lose their survival advantage over introduced species.
  • Traditional farmers whose farming patterns depend on the natural cycle of the river can suffer. For example, in the Nile Valley, traditional farmers received irrigation and natural fertilizer the annual floods, but after they dam was built, they could not get the water without paying,[verification needed], and had to pay for fertilizer instead of receiving free nutrient-rich sediment deposited by the flood.
  • Displacement of local people. Activists (including Arundhati RoyDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD.[verification needed])alleged that poor people are frequently thrown off their land with no choice, and little or no compensation.
  • Diseases spread by water may be an issue. For example the use of the Aswan DamDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD. for agriculture removed the traditional dry period, allowing snails to survive, spread, and act as intermediate hosts[verification needed] for the schistosomiasisDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD. pathogen, causing serious health problems to agricultural workers and others who had contact with the water.

These factors, and the fact that most suitable sites for dams have been dammed already, mean that other means of water supply are generally preferred. In some cases, old dams may actually be removed, or at least made to allow more water through (referred to as an environmental flowDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD.).

Of course, many factors must be considered, and the needs of the community may be such that a dam is required. In this case, design is very important:

  • Size no larger than necessary. This can be helped by emphasizing water efficiency in the community.
  • Use of fish ladderDEPRECATED TEMPLATE - PLEASE USE {{W}} INSTEAD. to minimize ecological impact. These should be designed for the local species.