We continue to develop resources related to the COVID-19 pandemic. See COVID-19 initiatives on Appropedia for more information.


Jump to navigation Jump to search

Air travel in academia

4,928 bytes added, 13 February
Extra ref
The individual emissions of academic researchers are high compared to other professionals, "primarily as a result of emissions from flying to conferences, project meetings, and fieldwork".<ref name="Tyndall"/><ref name="Fois 2016"/> Beyond their usefulness for doing research, these travels are motivated by career incentives, as decisions to award faculty positions or research funding depend in part on the applicants' activity as speakers at international conferences.
Touristic opportunities also contribute to motivating these travels, which are considered as a perk of the profession.<ref name="Tyndall"/>
While conferences and meetings are important for exchanging ideas and nurturing professional relationships, this can also be done using alternative modes of communication such as videoconferencing and social media. It has been argued that the benefits of face-to-face meetings might be outweighed by the benefits of the alternatives, such as reaching wider communities.<ref name="Tyndall"/>
==Attitudes =Attitude of academics and their academic institutions===
A 2014 study of three New Zealand universities found that rhetoric on sustainability coexisted with assumptions about the necessity to travel, and policies that encouraged travel.<ref name="nz14"/> A similar phenomenon was observed in Australia, where "a normative system of ‘academic aeromobility’ has developed".<ref name="Glover 2017"/> Australian universities could be divided into three groups, depending on whether they recognize the sustainability issues with air travel, and if yes whether they seek to substitute air travel with videoconferencing.<ref name="Glover 2018"/> ===Attitude of academics=== A 2017 survey found that conservationists' environmental footprint was only slightly lower than economics' and medics', and that exposure to environmental information had little impact on researchers' behaviour.<ref name="Balmford 2017"/> Flying often has been argued to be incompatible with anthropologists' research ethics.<ref name="anthro{dendum} 2018"/> In the case of archaeology, flying often while knowing about the problem of climate change has been denounced as a case of [[Wikipedia:cognitive dissonance|cognitive dissonance]].<ref name="Reynolds 2018"/> ===Climate hypocrisy===How much scientists fly affects their credibility when they communicate to the public on climate change.<ref name="Fois 2016"/> In particular, a 2016 survey has found that climate researchers' carbon footprints have a large effect on their credibility, and on participants' intentions to reduce their personal energy consumption.<ref name="Rosen 2017"/><ref name="Attari 2016"/>  The idea of researchers' climate hypocrisy regularly appears in media coverage of climate change. Hypocrisy discourses can be invoked both for supporting and for resisting climate-friendly policies.<ref name="Gunster 2018"/><ref name="Gunster 2"/>
==Emissions and their reduction==
===Estimated possible reductions===
Scientific organizations could reduce the carbon footprints of their meetings by up to 73% by alternating large national or international meetings with regional ones every other year, according to a 2011 study.<ref name="Rosen 2017"/>
Optimizing the locations of the conferences of the International Biogeography Society could reduce emissions by about 20%, according to a 2014 study.<ref name="sf14"/>
==Institutional policies==
===Taxes on air travel===
The [[Wikipedia:University of California, Los Angeles|University of California, Los Angeles]] has been taxing its departments $9 per domestic flight and $25 per international flight.<ref name="Hasan"/>
===Consequences of scientists' emissions on their credibility===
Important motivations for scientists to fly less are to lead by example, and to be more credible when communicating to the public on climate change.<ref name="Fois 2016"/> These motivations are particularly important in the case of climate scientists.
A 2016 survey has found that climate researchers' carbon footprints have a large effect on their credibility, and on participants' intentions to reduce their personal energy consumption.<ref name="Rosen 2017"/><ref name="Attari 2016"/>
===Voluntary reduction in air travel===
For researchers, reducing air travel is "the biggest opportunity for reducing personal climate impacts".<ref name="Rosen 2017"/>Some academics therefore reduce or stop flying in order to reduce their individual carbon footprints and/or to lead by example.
Meteorologist [[Wikipedia:Eric Holthaus|Eric Holthaus]] stopped flying in 2014, and claimed that slow travel made "his world shrink and become richer".<ref name="Holthaus"/>
==External links==
*[https://labos1point5.org/les-ressources/ Les ressources], a list of references including many on academic air travel, by [[Labos 1point5]].
*Parke Wilde's [https://academicflyingblog.wordpress.com/ Flying less] blog.
*International Civil Aviation Organization's [https://www.icao.int/environmental-protection/CarbonOffset/Pages/default.aspx carbon calculator].
<ref name="Fois 2016">{{cite journal | last=Fois | first=Mauro | last2=Cuena-Lombraña | first2=Alba | last3=Fristoe | first3=Trevor | last4=Fenu | first4=Giuseppe | last5=Bacchetta | first5=Gianluigi | title=Reconsidering alternative transportation systems to reach academic conferences and to convey an example to reduce greenhouse gas emissions | journal=History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences | publisher=Springer Science and Business Media LLC | volume=38 | issue=4 | year=2016 | issn=0391-9714 | doi=10.1007/s40656-016-0126-x | page=}}</ref>
<ref name="Rosen 2017">{{cite journal | last=Rosen | first=Julia | title=Sustainability: A greener culture | journal=Nature | publisher=Springer Science and Business Media LLC | volume=546 | issue=7659 | year=2017 | issn=0028-0836 | doi=10.1038/nj7659-565a | pages=565–567}}</ref>
<ref name="Balmford 2017">{{cite journal | last=Balmford | first=Andrew | last2=Cole | first2=Lizzy | last3=Sandbrook | first3=Chris | last4=Fisher | first4=Brendan | title=The environmental footprints of conservationists, economists and medics compared | journal=Biological Conservation | publisher=Elsevier BV | volume=214 | year=2017 | issn=0006-3207 | doi=10.1016/j.biocon.2017.07.035 | pages=260–269}}</ref>
<ref name="Glover 2017">{{cite journal | last=Glover | first=Andrew | last2=Strengers | first2=Yolande | last3=Lewis | first3=Tania | title=The unsustainability of academic aeromobility in Australian universities | journal=Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy | publisher=Informa UK Limited | volume=13 | issue=1 | year=2017 | issn=1548-7733 | doi=10.1080/15487733.2017.1388620 | pages=1–12}}</ref>
<ref name="Hasan">{{cite web | last=Hasan | first=Mejs | title=New University Rules Encourage Scientists to Avoid Air Travel | work=Wired | url=https://www.wired.com/story/climate-scientists-take-the-train/ | accessdate=2020-02-13}}</ref>
<ref name="anthro{dendum} 2018">{{cite web | title=In an era of climate change, our ethics code is clear: We need to end the AAA annual meeting | work=anthro{dendum} | date=2018-01-13 | url=https://anthrodendum.org/2018/01/13/climate-change-ethics-code-end-aaa-annual-meeting/ | accessdate=2020-02-13}}</ref>
<ref name="Glover 2018">{{cite journal | last=Glover | first=Andrew | last2=Strengers | first2=Yolande | last3=Lewis | first3=Tania | title=Sustainability and academic air travel in Australian universities | journal=International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education | publisher=Emerald | volume=19 | issue=4 | date=2018-05-08 | issn=1467-6370 | doi=10.1108/ijshe-08-2017-0129 | pages=756–772}}</ref>
<ref name="Gunster 2018">{{cite journal | last=Gunster | first=Shane | last2=Fleet | first2=Darren | last3=Paterson | first3=Matthew | last4=Saurette | first4=Paul | title=Climate Hypocrisies: A Comparative Study of News Discourse | journal=Environmental Communication | publisher=Informa UK Limited | volume=12 | issue=6 | date=2018-06-11 | issn=1752-4032 | doi=10.1080/17524032.2018.1474784 | pages=773–793}}</ref>
<ref name="Reynolds 2018">{{cite web | last=Reynolds | first=Natasha | title=Decarbonising archaeology | work=Nature Research Ecology & Evolution Community | date=2018-11-02 | url=https://natureecoevocommunity.nature.com/users/192514-natasha-reynolds/posts/40589-cognitive-dissonance-and-archaeological-practice-the-challenge-of-decarbonising-a-discipline | accessdate=2020-02-13}}</ref>
<ref name="Gunster 2">{{cite journal | last=Gunster | first=Shane | last2=Fleet | first2=Darren | last3=Paterson | first3=Matthew | last4=Saurette | first4=Paul | title=“Why Don't You Act Like You Believe It?”: Competing Visions of Climate Hypocrisy | journal=Frontiers in Communication | publisher=Frontiers Media SA | volume=3 | date=2018-11-06 | issn=2297-900X | doi=10.3389/fcomm.2018.00049 | page=}}</ref>
[[Category:Air travel]]


Navigation menu