Additional value of non-electricity generating services (co-benefits) provided by non-conventional dual use solar photovoltaic systems: A PRISMA review

▼Western University's Free Appropriate Sustainability Technology (FAST) Research Group

Wanted! Students to make a distributed future with solar-powered open-source 3-D printing and recycling. Contact Dr. Joshua Pearce - Apply here
Home · Projects & Publications · Methods · Literature reviews · People · Sponsors · News · Free Software · YouTube · LinkedIn · Github · For kids!

Solar photovoltaic (PV) systems play a pivotal role in the global transition to renewable energy, providing decentralized energy generation and socio-economic advantages. The land-use intensity of conventional PV, however, has led to growing interest in non-conventional systems such as floating PV (FPV), building-integrated PV (BIPV), agrivoltaics, PV carports, and grid-support applications. These alternatives offer additional non-electricity generation-related benefits, often overlooked by the prevailing evaluation metric in energy systems, the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE). While LCOE remains the dominant tool for assessing PV economics due to its simplicity, it fails to account for these non-electricity-related co-benefits, leading to an undervaluation of emerging PV technologies. To address this gap, a systematic review of 261 peer-reviewed articles was conducted using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) methodology. Thirteen categories of additional benefits were identified, with greenhouse gas emissions reduction (42.5 %) and water loss reduction (38.7 %) being the most frequently cited. Most studies, however, lacked a quantitative framework for integrating these benefits into overall PV economic evaluations. As a result, evaluation methods were discussed for each of these benefit categories, creating the foundation for a comprehensive framework that would evaluate non-conventional PV benefits. Additionally, significant inconsistencies in reporting critical PV attributes were identified, with only 25 % of studies reporting efficiency and 53 % specifying power ratings, making evaluation of PV co-benefits challenging. To address these shortcomings, this study proposes a standardized PV Nameplate Data table for academic PV studies encompassing key parameters such as location, module technology, efficiency, lifetime, power rating, and energy generation. Furthermore, the review underscores the necessity of developing open-source tools to systematically evaluate PV benefits; thereby enabling robust systems comparison, establishing comprehensive evaluation methodologies, improving system design, and informing policymakers’ decisions.

Data: https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/4VC7N

Lit Review: Additional Services Provided by Solar PV Systems: A review

▼Pearce publications

FAST · MOST · QAS

Agrivoltaics · Energy Conservation · Energy Policy · Floatovoltaics · Industrial Symbiosis · Life Cycle Analysis · Materials Science · Medical · Open Source · Photovoltaic Systems · Resilient Food · Solar Cells · Sustainable Development · Sustainability Education · Water

• Non-conventional PV systems, like FPV, BIPV, and agrivoltaics, offer diverse benefits.
• A PRISMA review of 261 studies identified 13 categories of additional PV benefits.
• Critical PV attributes, like efficiency, are inconsistently reported across studies.
• A standardized PV Nameplate Data table ensures consistent reporting of system attributes.
• Open-source tools are crucial for integrating benefits into comprehensive PV valuation.

The Western Innovation for Renewable Energy (WIRED) system is currently under construction to test out new open source methods to reduce PV systems costs and enable novel forms of agrivoltaics including the world's first agrivoltaic agrotunnel.

• 
  The Agrivoltaic Potential of Canada
• 
  Social acceptance of agrivoltaics in Canada: Insights on public perceptions across technologies and provinces from a nationwide survey
• 
  Net Zero Agrivoltaic Arrays for Agrotunnel Vertical Growing Systems: Energy Analysis and System Sizing
• 
  Regenerative Agrivoltaics: Integrating Photovoltaics and Regenerative Agriculture for Sustainable Food and Energy Systems
• 
  Agrivoltaics as a systems innovation: multi-dimensional benefits from global studies across climate, agriculture, energy, and ecosystems
• 
  Creating just agrivoltaic transitions for large-scale solar: a comparative multi criteria analysis
• 
  The potential of agrivoltaic systems to meet energy demand of data centers in the United States
• 
  Some like it hot, some like it partially shaded: The effect of semi-transparent solar photovoltaic modules on the growth metrics of greenhouse cultivated spicy peppers
• 
  Integration of semi-transparent photovoltaic modules and heat pumps into agrivoltaic tomato greenhouses: Energy, economic, and environmental savings
• 
  Strawberry agrivoltaics in Canada: Comparing uniform thin film and non-uniform crystalline silicon semi-transparent solar photovoltaic modules in controlled environment agriculture
• 
  Climate-Resilient Crop Production Under Agrivoltaics: Experimental Evaluation of Amaranth Production With Semi-Transparent Photovoltaic Modules in Canada Under Changing Climates
• 
  Is Non-Thermal Plasma Treatment of Commodity Lettuce Seeds Worth It? Economic Impacts and Yield of Lettuce in Indoor Vertical Farming Testing Dry Air, Wet Air, N2 and O2 Plasmas
• 
  Lighting Energy and Revenue Analysis in an Agrivoltaic Agrotunnel for Lettuce and Swiss Chard Production
• 
  Full Heads or Cut and Come Again? Economic Analysis of Leafy Green Cultivation in Solar-Powered Indoor Vertical Farms
• 
  Heat Stress Tolerance in Organic Romaine Lettuce Using Crystalline Silicon and Red, Blue & Green-Colored Thin Film Agrivoltaic Systems
• 
  Agrivoltaic Lettuce Production Under Future Climates: A Sustainable Strategy for Optimizing Food and Energy Yields
• 
  Effects of Thin-Film and Wafer-Based Photovoltaic Module Transparency and Spectral Properties on Microclimate and Turnip Yield in Agrivoltaic Systems
• 
  Sustainable Food–Energy Co-Production: Agrivoltaic Configurations that Maintain Organic Bean Yields and Enhance Farm
• 
  Semi-transparent neutral, red, green, and blue photovoltaics impacts on lettuce growth in agrivoltaic cold frames
• 
  Photosynthetically active radiation complexities in agrivoltaic policy mandates: Insights from controlled environment yields under semitransparent photovoltaics
• 
  Should Agrivoltaics Ever Be Decommissioned? How Agrivoltaics Bolster Farm Climate Adaptation Even When Unpowered
• 
  Transparency effects in agrivoltaics lettuce cultivation using uniform/non-uniform semitransparent photovoltaic modules in controlled environments
• 
  Impacts of Type of Partial Transparency on Strawberry Agrivoltaics: Uniform Illumination Thin Film Cadmium-Telluride and Non-uniform Crystalline Silicon Solar Photovoltaic Modules
• 
  Additional value of non-electricity generating services (co-benefits) provided by non-conventional dual use solar photovoltaic systems: A PRISMA review
• 
  An open-source spectral measurement platform for plant reflectance and material identification
• 
  Open-Source Photosynthetically Active Radiation Sensor for Enhanced Agricultural and Agrivoltaics Monitoring
• 
  Effects of Spectral Ranges on Growth and Yield in Vertical Hydroponic–Aeroponic Hybrid Grow Systems for Radishes and Turnips
• 
  Financial Analysis of Agrivoltaic Sheep: Breeding and Auction Lamb Business Models
• 
  Experimental impacts of transparency on strawberry agrivoltaics using thin film photovoltaic modules under low light conditions
• 
  Open-Source Indoor Horizontal Grow Structure Designs
• 
  Greenhouse applications of solar photovoltaic driven heat pumps in northern environments
• 
  Solar Energy Modelling and Proposed Crops for Different Types of Agrivoltaics Systems
• 
  Maximizing Biomass with Agrivoltaics: Potential and Policy in Saskatchewan Canada
• 
  Energy Policy for Agrivoltaics in Alberta Canada
• 
  Agrivoltaics in Ontario Canada: Promise and Policy
• 
  Energy Modeling and Techno-Economic Feasibility Analysis of Greenhouses for Tomato Cultivation Utilizing the Waste Heat of Cryptocurrency Miners
• 
  Advancing Agrivoltaics within the U.S. Legal Framework: A Multidimensional Assessment of Barriers & Opportunities
• 
  Low cost climate station for smart agriculture applications with photovoltaic energy and wireless communication
• 
  Design and Implementation of 3-D Printed Radiation Shields for Environmental Sensors
• 
  Design of a low-cost mobile multispectral albedometer with geopositioning and absolute orientation
• 
  Parametric Open Source Cold-Frame Agrivoltaic Systems
• 
  Impacts of Location on Designs and Economics of DIY Low-Cost Fixed-Tilt Open Source Wood Solar Photovoltaic Racking
• 
  Open-Source Design and Economics of Manual Variable-Tilt Angle DIY Wood-Based Solar Photovoltaic Racking System
• 
  Solar photovoltaic wood racking mechanical design for trellis-based agrivoltaics
• 
  Open-Source Vertical Swinging Wood-Based Solar Photovoltaic Racking Systems
• 
  Vertical Free-Swinging Photovoltaic Racking Energy Modelling: A Novel Approach to Agrivoltaics
• 
  Optimal inverter and wire selection for solar photovoltaic fencing applications
• 
  The potential for fencing to be used as low-cost solar photovoltaic racking
• 
  Do agrivoltaics improve public support for solar? A survey on perceptions, preferences, and priorities
• 
  Greener Sheep: Life Cycle Analysis of Integrated Sheep Agrivoltatic Systems
• 
  Life cycle assessment of pasture-based agrivoltaic systems: Emissions and energy use of integrated rabbit production
• 
  Conceptual Design and Rationale for a New Agrivoltaics Concept: Pastured-Raised Rabbits and Solar Farming
• 
  Integrating solar energy with agriculture: Industry perspectives on the market, community, and socio-political dimensions of agrivoltaics
• 
  A First Investigation of Agriculture Sector Perspectives on the Opportunities and Barriers for Agrivoltaics
• 
  Open-Source Script for Design and 3D Printing of Porous Structures for Soil Science
• 
  Agrivoltaic potential on grape farms in India
• 
  Aquavoltaics: Synergies for dual use of water area for solar photovoltaic electricity generation and aquaculture
• 
  The potential of agrivoltaic systems
• 
  Solar Photovoltaic Powered On-Site Ammonia Production for Nitrogen Fertilization
• 
  Open-Source Photometric System for Enzymatic Nitrate Quantification
• 
  Open-source manufacturing of polypropylene replacements for peat cups in vertical farming: improvements in life cycle embodied energy, greenhouse gas emissions, labor and operational costs
• 
  Agrivoltaics Canada

• Coal with Carbon Capture and Sequestration is not as Land Use Efficient as Solar Photovoltaic Technology for Climate Neutral Electricity Production
• Dual use of land for PV farms and agriculture literature review
• sheep
• Israeli white plastic reflectors

• A Farmer's Guide to Going Solar (NREL)
• German guidelines: https://www.ise.fraunhofer.de/content/dam/ise/en/documents/publications/studies/APV-Guideline.pdf
• 2021 review
• Miskin, C.K., Li, Y., Perna, A., Ellis, R.G., Grubbs, E.K., Bermel, P. and Agrawal, R., 2019. Sustainable co-production of food and solar power to relax land-use constraints. Nature Sustainability, 2(10), pp.972-980.
• Retrofitting solar parks for agrivoltaics
• Shading PV
• Alexis' talk at American Solar Grazing Association2021

1. Solar Sheep, Alberta (https://www.solarsheep.ca/)
2. Sun Cycle Farms, Alberta (https://suncyclefarms.com/)
3. Golden Leaf Agrivoltaics, Ontario (https://goldenleafagrivoltaics.ca/)
4. The Lara Cost Farm, Ontario (https://thelaracosta.com/)
5. Arnprior Solar, Ontario (https://www.edf-re.com/project/arnprior-solar/)
6. Lewis Land & Stock, Ontario (https://solargrazing.org/asga-call-29-don-lewis-from-lewis-land-stock-of-ontario-canada/)
7. Nanticoke Solar, Ontario (https://www.opg.com/stories/hundreds-of-grazing-sheep-helping-to-keep-opgs-nanticoke-solar-facility-in-trim-shape/)
8. Western University’s Western Innovation for Renewable Energy Deployment (WIRED) (https://www.appropedia.org/Western_Innovation_for_Renewable_Energy_Deployment_(WIRED))
9. Orchard, Middlesex, Ontario
10. Solar Grazing Map https://solargrazing.org/map/

The Western Innovation for Renewable Energy (WIRED) system is currently under construction to test out new open source methods to reduce PV systems costs and enable novel forms of floatovoltaics, BIPV and agrivoltaics including the world's first agrivoltaic agrotunnel.

• 
  Design and thermal-energy performance analysis of foam-based floating photovoltaic systems in a cold climate: experimental results from a 7 kW floatovoltaics in Canada
• 
  Additional value of non-electricity generating services (co-benefits) provided by non-conventional dual use solar photovoltaic systems: A PRISMA review
• 
  Experimental integration of a foam-based floating photovoltaic (floatovoltaic) system with an anion exchange membrane electrolyzer for 5 kW-Scale green hydrogen production
• 
  Performance of Off-grid Floating Photovoltaic-Battery System Powering an Anion Exchange Membrane Electrolyser for Green Hydrogen Production
• 
  The Greenest Solar Power? Life Cycle Assessment of Foam-Based Flexible Floatovoltaics
• 
  Foam-based floatovoltaics: A potential solution to disappearing terminal natural lakes
• 
  Water Conservation Potential of Self-Funded Foam-Based Flexible Surface-Mounted Floatovoltaics
• 
  Distributed manufacturing of after market flexible floating photovoltaic modules
• 
  Aquavoltaics: Synergies for dual use of water area for solar photovoltaic electricity generation and aquaculture

• Technical Solar Photovoltaic Potential of Scaled Parking Lot Canopies- A Case Study of Walmart U.S.A.
• Electric Vehicle Charging Potential from Retail Parking Lot Solar Photovoltaic Awnings
• Performance and analysis of retail store‐centered microgrids with solar photovoltaic parking lot, cogeneration, and battery‐based hybrid systems
• Open-source Photovoltaic - Electrical Vehicle Carport Designs
• Power and energy potential of mass-scale photovoltaic noise barrier deployment- A case study for the U.S.
• PV deployed on noise barriers literature review